HUGE BACHELOR SPOILER: Who Does Jason Mesnick Pick?
Published on: January 15, 2009 – 1:06 pm by Jillian Madison
Comment

HEY EVERYBODY! Jillian Madison will be live-blogging THE BACHELOR (JASON) FINALE EPISODE on 3/2/09. Click here to read the episode recap — or keep reading for some spoilers.
Don’t worry, we won’t type her name out here. But if you want to know which girl Jason Mesnick gets engaged to, watch the video below.
Other posts on Pophangover:













January 17th, 2009
Well after watching this Video I did some researched of my own. So just to let everyone know at the end of the clip it showed Jason on one knee and a girl with a pinky ring. well its not even from this season. Its from the bachelorette when he asked DeAnna to marry him. If you look back at that season finale you will see that’s DeAnna Dress and it shows Deann face and her hand with the pinky ring. So it’s not even a clip from the real finale from this season. Well just thought you should know.
January 17th, 2009
OK maybe im wrong who knows??? the dress is diffrent was looking at a diffrent clip!!
January 18th, 2009
IF he’s right, I’m thrilled. I liked her right away.
But more importantly, I could sit (ok, LAY… I’m freaking SICK) here all day and listen to him say the word “out” repeatedly. CUTE!
January 19th, 2009
Well, that picture is not from the Bachelorette, as Deanna wore a teal dress, strapless, check out the scenery, as it is not the same greenery as what Deanna stood on waiting for choice.
January 19th, 2009
Other sites have matched up moles on the girl’s arm as well. I’m 99% sure Jason DOES choose the woman mentioned in the video.
January 20th, 2009
Well done. It’s easy to track people like that. Just have to do the work to find it.
January 20th, 2009
When Jason proposed to DeAnna, he was wearing a blue shirt with an orange tie. This clip is def. not from last season.
January 21st, 2009
Stephanie also wears pinky rings a lot!
January 21st, 2009
Yes Jennifer, which is why they matched up moles on the girl’s arm and hand, proving that Melissa is the girl Jason chooses.
January 24th, 2009
i agree with eyeris . he def. picks melissa i have benn reseaching for bout three weeks. i have a major the art of body language. i was watching the bonnie hunt show and she told jason that she new that he picked her . jason got really fijjity and started to blush and then he talked about melissa’s smile three times after that . to i am not 100 % positive. but i would put money down on melissa . oh yeah the whole mole thing is pretty accurate too.
January 25th, 2009
When the girl in question came out of the limo, I had in my notes (definitely final 3 if not further). Damn I am good.
January 26th, 2009
i was hoping he picked stefanie! she’s so classy and had a little girl – it would have been a ready made family. darn! i hope they have stefanie on next season then…she’s so wonderful and has a sad story to boot.
January 26th, 2009
I just went to a link that showed Deanna on the finale – her dress is strapless… now rewatch Jason on one knee in this clip and notice the dress has a strap over the left shoulder. So the person who said it’s not this season but it’s Deanna, didn’t look too carefully at the dress. It can’t go from strapless to a strap suddenly… Check it out for yourself… I also wanted Stephanie but Melissa was my second choice.
http://images.eonline.com/eol_images/Entire_Site/20080707/293.depappas.bachelorette2.070708.jpg
January 26th, 2009
if you look at all the contestants, melissa wears the pinky ring on her right hand, as shown in the video. i was scared for a minute b.c stephanie wears a pinky ring too… but on her left!
January 26th, 2009
[...] (For more info on this episode, including photos and funny recaps, visit our friends at Pophangover! And if you’d like to know which girl Jason picks, click here to read a spoiler!) [...]
January 26th, 2009
ok i checked and its not the deanna dress, hers had no straps and jason definately had on a blue shirt with deanna, this shirt is white. yes stephanie wears pinky rings, you CANT go by this jerks prediction, JUST HAVE TO WAIT AND SEE huh lol
January 26th, 2009
stephanie also wears a pinky ring on her right hand, see the video with her little girl done by a reporter in her hometown
January 27th, 2009
However, he would have kissed Stephanie by now. He’s had every opportunity – several of my friends have been watching – he definitely has the spark and concern for Melissa. We think he admires and likes Stephanie as a person but the romance isn’t there. I wanted it to be but I can tell it’s not happening for him. He took Molly to a tent all night. If it’s there, he’ll kiss her and he hasn’t even tried. I think the final two are Melissa and Jillian or Melissa and Naomi. I did notice he is the first bachelor to weed out every crazy and get it down to 5 who seem stable. Nikkie reminded me too much of Deanna – a need to be in control, too much drama and tears. When she said she can’t be more perfect or prettier – what is she talking about? I never found her attractive and even if I had, I can’t believe she doesn’t see room for improvement – everyone does. She killed it when she said she doesn’t have a silly side. He needs someone to have one – he has a kid! Who wants a serious perfectionistic control freak if you can have someone fun loving. And I don’t know what Lauren was thinking but getting angry with him was the way wrong approach! Amazing they all thought they were the best match for him – none of the others said that – and he got rid of them. They really don’t see themselves.
January 27th, 2009
but guess what? the girl they preview in the cliffhanger season finale clip has a french manicure and melissa doesn’t wear french manicures, but stephanie does! melissa wears the darker colors. i hope stephanie is the winner…she deserves a second chance at love. can you see melissa a mom to a five year old at 25…and that’s what he is looking for! go step!
January 27th, 2009
Guys,
you’re forgetting they have also matched up the MOLES ON THE GIRLS ARM AND HANDS, and after taking all that into account, it is definitely Melissa. Not Stephanie.
January 27th, 2009
He is not looking for a mom for Ty, Ty already has a mom who he is close to. Jason is looking for a partner for him and a mentor and friend to Ty, and he said that in an interview to People. I’m pretty sure its Melissa.
January 27th, 2009
The preview I saw showed him putting a ring on a girl’s left hand. She had fake nails. Melisssa doesn’t. It looked like Stephanie’s hand to me.
January 27th, 2009
Only for special occasions have I ever had fake nails – proms, special events where I had a manicure like my wedding. You don’t think it’s possible if you think there’s a chance you are being proposed to that you might have your nails done? Don’t you think people help them with their hair and makeup? It’s all part of the season finale LOL If I’m going to wear a gown, I’m going to make sure my nails are done…. And I rewatched their dance scene… Stephanie wears her pinky ring on the left hand. Melissa does on her right hand. The girl being proposed to had it on her right hand. And I see more chemistry with Melissa and more of an admiration and commonality having children with Stephanie. They talked more with her daughter on their date. I really pushed for Stephanie with my friends but even I had to admit as I watch more episodes, he doesn’t seem that into her like he is with Naomi and Melissa. And I just went and looked at the photo stills on the Bachelor website from the episodes. Melissa has red nails by the poolside… then no polish on last night’s date. I guess like hairstyles, we can also change our nails! I looked for a still with the mole – haven’t been able to find a good one where I can see the mole. But the dancing ones with Stephanie – you can clearly see her arms and she wears her ring – looks like a pearl maybe – on her right pinky finger and it looked like a band of somesort on her right ring finger – but was hard to see when they picked their glasses up and toasted.
January 27th, 2009
I dont know why people dwell on the french manicure… how hard is it to get french nails… and also if you are the two last ladies and you might get proposed to on TV you dont think you would get a nice and pretty manicure before… thats so not a clue.
January 27th, 2009
Also, i just went through some clips on YouTube and Melissa wears the french tips too everynow and then.
January 27th, 2009
I too saw last night’s episode and Stephanie’s ring is on her left hand’s pinkie not right hand like the video.
But who knows it could be either one of them and they are all tricking us.
January 27th, 2009
But have you seen much chemistry between him and Stephanie as you have with Melissa? It’s hard not to be really nice to someone who has been nothing but stable acting and very kind towards you. She’s very motherly and it comes naturally to her. She’s funny and polite to everyone but no matter how nice and right she seems, Jason has to find her more appealing beyond a great friend. He has to have romantic feelings towards her and he wasn’t sure if he had any – he said that. I’m thinking it could be Melissa and Naomi who make it to the final two. I think he likes that Naomi has only been with one person and told him that the relationship was a good one. That means usually not too much baggage coming with her and that she can manage a good relationship with another person. Molly still behaves quite young. She wanted the others to be jealous of the overnight date. I don’t see him with her. I didn’t notice anymore chemistry with Jillian last night either.
January 28th, 2009
i want him to pick stephnie soo baad she is just amarzing.pls let it be her sooo bad.
January 28th, 2009
Melissa’s ring is silver and on her RIGHT hand. It is a ring that all Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders receive when they make the squad. He asks Melissa!
January 28th, 2009
http://i578.photobucket.com/albums/ss221/sjtomsen/l_0a392d99d3ad4de0b79f2e17b244ebd0.jpg
Here ya go. Some DCC friends of mine with their pinkie rings.
January 28th, 2009
To comment on what Heather said, Jason wore a blue shirt and orange tie during the bachelorette finale, and in this clip he is wearing a white shirt and blue tie so i would really like to know where you got your research from? oh ya and Deanna’s dress was strapless…plus my theory is that he ends up with Melissa, because I just don’t see him with the any of the other girls…But I could be totally wrong…It’s just a theory after all!
January 29th, 2009
Sara….Bingo! You are right on.
January 29th, 2009
Sara, you totally confirmed what i thought. It’s Melissa!
Zero chemistry with Stephanie. It’s like watching Jason with his mother and it’s just gross. I hope she leaves soon.
January 29th, 2009
i completely agree, its like watching jason with his mom.
but heather your wrong, she was wearing a blue dress not a white dress. and uhm natalie and stefanie wear gold pinky rings to soo, uh thanks captain obvious.
idk which girl i like. i hate stefanie. but i hope he chooses molly or jillian in the end. i do like melissa to. NOT NAOMI! puke.
=]
January 30th, 2009
about the manicures; they change them . on the first one on one date with mel, she had the french manicure. i remember b/c i turned to my friends and i was like omg that ’s the hand of the girl in the finale. so has time to do that. i still dunno if it’s her but ya. i liked jillian tho notsuper much. i can’t stand molly, i disliked her from when she came out of the limo “let me see ya golf swing, yaaa, yaaa”
oh god.
January 31st, 2009
I love Stephanie. She’s so realy and she will realy make a good wife and a mother figure to Ty. she is just so mature unlike the other girls…I just hope He peaks HER….
February 2nd, 2009
I think Melissa looks/acts very similar to Deanna and thought that from the first time I saw her. He definitely has a type. I hope it works out for him and Ty.
February 3rd, 2009
Ok, now that Steph is GONE… who will it be.. I am pulling for Melissa.. I didnt like her at first, but she’s grown on me. I dont really think any of the others are really a match for him… we’ll see….
February 3rd, 2009
Last night 2/2/09 Jillian had on a pinkie ring when Jason took her for a walk to talk!!!! I have it DVR’d and it’s true, just watched it to confirm….don’t know what to believe….guess I’ll just have to keep watching!
February 3rd, 2009
Where is the video to watch????
February 5th, 2009
I was just going to say that. I thought Gillian had a pinky ring on during the last episode. For awhile now I have thought the final 2 will be Molly and Melissa with Melissa winning. But then I saw how much he does like Gillian and it would not suprise me if the final 2 will be Melissa and Gillian. I think Niomi is the next to go and either Molly or Gillian will be the next to go over that. Pretty interesting, LOL! Gillian is growing on me!
February 9th, 2009
[...] (For more info on this episode, including photos and funny recaps, visit our friends at Pophangover! And if you’d like to know which girl Jason picks, click here to read a spoiler!) [...]
February 10th, 2009
You rock! Great work looking back for the pinky ring.
February 10th, 2009
that is not deannas dress her dress was like two tone darker blue with green and it was strapless not one shoulder. So that is a diff dress
February 10th, 2009
I fear it is Melissa, what jock doesn’t go for the giggly cheerleader? She’s too young, too immature, not ready to be mom yet. I think Stephanie would have been the one they needed more time together. They have a connection as friends and with appropriate dating or courtship I think they would have ended up together.
February 10th, 2009
Bonnie Hunt announced that Melissa was going to win too on her show.
February 10th, 2009
I really like Melissa, was the one picked for him weeks ago. She is cute, perky and they look great together. What was it about Naomi that he kicked her off?
February 11th, 2009
If he chooses Melissa, I’ll have to rethink his brain power!
She is too young, too immature and definitely not marriage material at this time.
My pick is Jillian! She’s the one!
February 15th, 2009
Just because the person that he picked was wearing a gold pinkie ring and so was Melissa in one of the episodes doesn’t mean thats who he picks.
February 16th, 2009
[...] (For more info on this episode, including photos and funny live-blogging episode recaps, visit our friends at Pophangover! And if you’d like to know which girl Jason picks, click here to read a spoiler!) [...]
February 17th, 2009
Why is everyone here saying who he should pick. It’s not up to anyone to pick anyone for him it’s how HE feels not everyone else. Of course we have our favorites but be happy for him because who he chooses I’m sure is coming from the heart.
February 17th, 2009
UGh I cant believe he kicked off Jill, She was definatly the best marriage material out of them all! Melissa is so immature and cant stand how fake her talk and stupid laugh is. If he decides to go with her they will NEVER last!
February 17th, 2009
I am absolutely stunned that Jason sent Jillian packing! He is nuts! There is no way that Melissa is ready for the responsibilities of marriage. She is too immature, and the lack of family participation on her part sends up a lot of red flags.
February 17th, 2009
I think that Molly should have gone last night, but I am still glad that Melissa is there. Yes, she is young. But she does seem to be more matronly than Molly. If you’ve been watching all along, you’ll know that she planned to become a first grade teacher as well, so I think that shows that she will be loving and patient with Ty. I hope that she does win, and if the video is correct, that might come true.
February 17th, 2009
Just wanted to let you guys know that its not DeAnna in that picture of Jason proposing on here. I went back and watched the final rose ceremony from when DeAnna dumped Jason, and its a different dress. The dress on here shows a strap, DeAnna’s dress had no strap and you could see her hair in the picture as well so I think whoever the girl is in this picture is the one he actually chooses, not DeAnna. I truly hope he picks Melissa, I think he seems the happiest with her. Molly is great too, I just really like Melissa!!!
February 17th, 2009
Then what’s this “shocking” ending all about if Melissa is chosen? Nothing shocking there. Anyone of these women could be wearing a pinkie ring. They might have shown this to throw everyone off. I don’t buy that J didn’t have feelings for Jillian. Maybe she ends up back on the show. Who knows.
February 17th, 2009
Ladies, just some food for thought. The moles may or may not have been digitally enhanced to make it look like Melissa, could be? However, if Deanna is back in the picture and she wears a pinkie ring as well. Maybe, just maybe she is wearing a different dress for this season finale and he picks her. It could be possible, how hard is it to get a different dress? I agree that the clips can be arranged to throw everyone off but so can spoilers. I am eager to see who he really does pick!!!
February 17th, 2009
That isn’t the scene from Deanna. She wore a strapless darker blue dress. This is this year.
He has to pick Melissa-there is no way he’ll pick Molly.
And I think Deanna comes back to give advice.
February 17th, 2009
Wrong people–this clip is NOT from him proposing to DeAnna on the bachelorette. When he proposed to D he was wearing an orange tie–remember, he wore it for good luck because it was Ty’s fav. color. Youtube it if you don’t believe me. So, looks like Melissa it is–ABC can’t deny their video glitch gives it away!
February 17th, 2009
Jennifer: Stephanie is alreadyeliminated, so why would he propose to her? He’s gonna pick Melissa,just to let y’all know! :D
February 17th, 2009
I am so looking forward to seeing the final episode. I agree with a lot of comments made. I really like Melissa and I like Molly. i have to admit I don’t know anything about DeAnna, (I missed that season). But I am still watching the final episode of this season for myself.
February 17th, 2009
He does not propose to Deanna again…she already has another boyfriend after dumping Jessie. Im rooting for Melissa….
February 18th, 2009
I too heard that he picks Melissa……..BUT,when they go back to do the After the Final Rose episode Jason breaks up with Melissa and gets with Molly…
….take it for what it’s worth….we’ll see in a couple weeks.
February 19th, 2009
It’s all over the internet now that yes, Jason will propose to Melissa in the finale (no surprise; that’s what had been intentionally leaked to us some time ago), but during the first “After the Final Rose” he will break his engagement to Melissa and tell her it’s over; he’s starting a relationship with Molly. The next night there will be “ATFR 2″ during which we’ll find out how he and Molly have been doing. Supposedly this has been planned all season long. Jason knew it; the girls didn’t. If it’s true, Melissa gets royally screwed in the end.
February 19th, 2009
Ok, So ready for the real scoop. He does pick Melissa and then at the after the rose ceremony “The Drama” they keep talking about is: He dumps Melissa and tells them that he is on love with Molly and has been all along. And from what ive read, they will have a second after the rose ceremony and it will be him with Molly. There is a guy Reality Steve and he never gives out spoliers but he was so mad this time he did. And he says that this information is for sure…. So lets watch and see if he is right?
February 22nd, 2009
Good JOb!!
February 23rd, 2009
Well I did my research and this is indeed from this season. Because in last season Jason was wearing a blue shirt and Deanna had on a darker blue dress on which was strapless. Just youtube jasons proposal to Deanna and you will see. I love Melissa so please let it be her!
February 24th, 2009
Ok so I just read that he does pick Melissa! But between the final episode and the taping of the Final Rose show that they do, Jason and Molly secretly start dating! So on the Final Rose show part 2 that they are advertising Jason and Molly announce their relationship and Jason call off the engagement to Melissa! If that happenes I will be so pissed that I will never watch this show again!!!!!
I am cheering on Melissa.
February 24th, 2009
Why would they not have an audience in the studio just because he decided to go with Molly instead of Melissa? Also, how would he have been able to date Molly after the show finished taping when he wouldn’t even have been able to date Melissa (the girl he supposedly chose) except for clandestine meetings set up by the show? I think it is more plausible that he chooses Melissa, that the final taping is private so that her family, who didn’t want to be in the public eye, would attend the taping so he could meet them??? Who knows?
February 24th, 2009
Actually i did some research as well. The dress DeAnna was wearing when she didn’t pick Jason didn’t have straps. I agree with the video. The dress DeAnna wore was also a darker blue and green color so there you have it people…….he picks Mellisa!!!!But now I’m not so sure beause DeAnna came back and said that she made the biggest mistake of her life. Which I agree! But it all depends what color dress ,or if DeAnna wears a dress, DeAnna wears. But, I honestly think he picks Mellisa!! I know for a fact that he doesn’t pick Molly. I’m pretty sure he wouldn’t just all of a sudden propose to DeAnna especially without dating her again. So all though I like DeAnna I’d say MELLISA and I’m 99% sure MELLISA is the one!!!!She is and do research you’ll believe me:)
February 24th, 2009
Thank you for posting this. Just say the show the show the “Ladies tell all” and I really did have the feeling that Molly was just too stiff and not that much personality. Melissa seems nice and great for his son too.
February 25th, 2009
Yeah I don’t like Molly! Why he likes her is beyond me. I liked Jillian for him but i guess that wasn’t going to happen. I heard rumors that Jason picks Mellisa and breaks the engagement and goes with Molly. I also heard that they told him if he wanted Molly he had to pick Mellisa and then go with Molly. I know that isn’t true because that isn’t the point of the show. The point is to find someone you want to spend the rest of your life with. They wouldn’t make Jason do that. So I still believe it’s Mellisa.
February 25th, 2009
OKay, did anyone see the scenes last week when the two girls are geting ready? Did anyone notice that both of the girls have on gold pinky rings? and that both of the girls have french manicured fingers? Very curious to know what is going to happen! I wish next week would get here already.
February 25th, 2009
if you watch the video the woman Jason proposes to has a pinky ring on her left hand and when he shows Melissa having a pinky ring it is on her right hand so I don’t feel this guy is doing anything but getting his name and website out there for people to watch. Must be nice sleeping at night knowing you lie to others.
February 26th, 2009
If Jason does indeed pick Melissa then dumps her shortly thereafter for Molly, it will underscore the “theme” in Melissa’s life that she is always the “dumpee.”
February 26th, 2009
I don’t believe for one second that Jason dumps Melissa for Molly. I think that’s just hype being drummed up by an ABC employee.
If Jason doesn’t dump Melissa until AFTER the show ends, then why would the final rose ceremony be “so shocking that they had to do it with an empty studio?” Simply giving a rose to Melissa is NOT SO SHOCKING. So something else has to happen.
February 26th, 2009
In Entertainment magazine there is a bachelor interview that says that Chris always says, “this will be the most dramatic rose ceremony ever”. Also he always says when its time to give out the final rose at a ceremony that “this is the final rose”. He says it just became a thing that stuck because viewers made comments that he always said it and joked about it. Also I do not believe this reality Steve spoiler. Its just to get people hyped. In “In Touch” magazine Deanna supposedly said she came back because ABC asked her to add drama. Also that she is now currently dating some guy from Real World Paris.
February 26th, 2009
If Jason picks Melissa, then dumps her for Molly or even DeAnna, Melissa’s family was right not to get involved with the show. I don’t think Jason is the guy we all thought he was last season. If the show manipulated the outcome, why are any of us watching?
February 27th, 2009
If you look at the pictures of Melissa and of Molly at the final rose ceremony- neither are wearing a blue dress (Melissa – yellow & Molly – purple)- so……either he does not propose to one of them OR the video of him proposing to a woman in a blue dress was just a set up to throw us bloggers off and he really does propose to Melissa or Molly
The other entries are right – it is not a video from the ceremony with Deanna b/c his shirt and tie are different as well as the dress is not the same.
February 27th, 2009
guys…
he picks melissa at first and gives her the ring and everything but he changes his mind and picks molley!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i feel so smart. he picks both of them so woopa!
i loved jillian though!
February 27th, 2009
oh man i feel stupid now! lol
i meant molly!
but really, thats what happens =)
i know right, AMAZING!
February 28th, 2009
hey i have no idea who he married but i just wish someone would no exactly who it is !!! i cant wait too see… i dont think deeanna deserves a second chance
March 1st, 2009
I JUST FREAKIN TOLD YOU!
and i know for sure im right.
picks melissa, changes his mind, picks molly.
so there ya go.
March 2nd, 2009
Hey WOOP,
I’d like to see your proof. Where are you hearing this? For all I know you’re making this up…..
March 2nd, 2009
This has been a very very crazy night! i really think that he is right with Molly, and hope that Molly will take him back. Both of the girls are so sweet, and Melissa does deserve the absolute best!
March 3rd, 2009
All i know so far is that he did pick Mellisa, he was with her for 6 weeks,apparently there over! done .. no more!
and Jason is in “love” with molly still and she i guess took him back as long as they talk about stuff for awhile to get shit straight!
but i dont know who he is gonna take take.. well have to see..
i liked the Mellisa and the girl from Canada
March 3rd, 2009
HAHA.
Hey AMANDA!
do you still think i was making it up?
i know what im talkin about :)
March 3rd, 2009
but doesnt everyone agree with me when i say JASON MESNICK IS THE BIGGEST JERK EVER! MELISSA DID NOT DESERVE THAT! I HATE HIM
April 23rd, 2009
Why is Jason a jerk? Didn’t he do the exact same thing that Deanna Pappas did? First, he fell in love with the bachelorette. Deanna, in turn, fell in love wiht Brad. Then he was dumped by her and proposed to Melissa. Deanna was dumped by Brad and accepted Jesse’s proposal. Then, a few months later, he realized he wasn’t in love with his fiancee and dumped her in order to ask Molly out. Deanna broke off the engagement with Jesse and came back to Jason’s show to confess that she had made a mistake and would like another chance.
Deanna is Ellen’s BFF and Jason is a jerk? What’s the difference??
I’m just grateful that Jason didn’t drag it out forever, but made his change early so we can all get on with our lives.
In my book, the real hero here is Brad Womack. Not one single Bachelor in history has actually married the woman he gave the final rose to, but Brad is the only one who had the balls and the honesty to let us know at the Final Rose that he wouldn’t be making that step off the cliff. And for that rare show of integrity, he was vilified and dragged through the mud, particularly by Ellen.
Thank you, Brad for showing us that real gentlemen still live!